Helpful. When I run a packet capture I am seeing tcp out of order messages. Then, interVRF matches interZone and intraVRF matches intraZone. LACP and LLDP Pre-Negotiation for Active/Passive HA. Device Priority and Preemption. When the active firewall goes down, the floating IP address moves from the active to the passive firewall so that the passive firewall can seamlessly secure traffic as soon as it becomes the active peer. and if we disconnect po110, po111 will work. Our network engineer is opting for a complete HSRP Active/Active environment. Connect the HA ports to set up a physical connection between the firewalls. Honestly, you should try really hard to avoid it. Both firwalls will synchronise their network, object, and policy configurations plus session information. User account menu. Problems can arrive when the failed member rejoins. Click Accept as Solution to acknowledge that the answer to your question has been provided. Posted in : Network, Palo Alto By Jimmy Dao 1 year ago. The member who gave the solution and all future visitors to this topic will appreciate it! It has its use case, but it really complicates troubleshooting. Does that make sense? Active/active mode is recommended if each firewall needs its own routing instances and you require full, real-time redundancy out of both firewalls all the time. Active/Passive vs. Active/Active General Topics. po110 work while po111 will not work. You can create a 0.0.0.0/0 static route on the PAN and redistribute from there. Close. If one firewalls fails for any reason, the other firewall can take over with minimal loss of service. Active Monitoring. Version 9.1; Version 9.0; Version 8.1; Version 8.0 (EoL) Version 10.0; Jump … Palo Alto – What Settings Don’t Sync in Active/Active HA? If PANa is the session owner but PANb receives the packet, it will forward the packet over to the session owner (HA3/HSCI). For example: Let's say you have a single PAN vRouter and all of it's attached interfaces (ie - VRFs on the 9K) all in an OSPF area 0. Set Up Active/Passive HA. Active/Passive HA Configuration in Palo Alto Firewall: HA Ports: We do not have any dedicated HA1 and HA2 ports. L3-p2p? I think focusing on the Core Switch Layer (nexus/cat9k) that has multiple VRFs that egress Layer 3 routed ports on the Core to the Core Palo FW. Active/Active was designed for networks with asymmetric routing. This is great for preventing layer 2 loops when the active and passive device are simply an alternate path for the same traffic. Passive vs. So OSPF is doing ecmp to loopbacks from 9500s to palos, palos doing ecmp to each 9500. Should my ha session options be different than they are? Steps: Login to the active device through webui https://PA-FW-IP-Address; Go to Device; Click on high availability; Click on operational commands; Click “Suspend local device” Now secondary firewall will move to Active status. 14:53. (This last part in thanks to my Panorama instructor). This option along with preemption can lead to preemptive loop, refer:When does an HA node go into Suspended state due to Preemption loop ? When two Palo Alto Networks firewalls are deployed in an active/passive cluster, it is mandatory to configure the device priority. )7K1(VPC) Palo2(Passive)(Inside seg) >>> (L2? VWire Active/Passive, Active/Active Best Practices. Are there any issues when using the PA's in an A/A configuration for VPN termination, etc...? I am currently working on a network redesign project with all Cisco gear. Home; VM-Series; VM-Series Deployment Guide ; Set Up the VM-Series Firewall on AWS; High Availability for VM-Series Firewall on AWS; Configure Active/Passive HA on AWS; Download PDF. Floating IP Address and Virtual MAC Address . No leaking necessary. Active/active is required is if your infratructure requires communication be permitted between devices connected to the secondary firewall at all times. jfigueroa8. ACTIVE VS PASSIVE DEFENSE May 16, 2017 Brian Samuels 1 Credits • The majority of this material I learned from Debbie Rosenberg • Current slides have a few differences from the handouts, so if you want these latest, please print them from our website • paloaltobridge.com– wait a day or 2 for them to be posted 2. But if you network design is fully active/active and therefore there is traffic such as bgp, vrrp, or other protocols that need to communicate on secondary links at all times, you must have the PAN cluster setup as active/active. In addition to the failover lag time, this active passive HA cannot span multiple Availability Zones due to the AWS limitation of not allowing ENI moves to span AZs. If the OSPF/BGP,etc protocol come up before the firewalls are completely synced, you will get some drops. Palo Alto Active/Passive > eBGP to ISP > VLANs for ToR switches (Juniper) - (‎07-31-2019 09:34 AM) General Topics by Cdchamberlin on ‎07-31-2019 09:34 AM … Active/Passive Link State. You have to think of them as 2 routers that just happen to shared a session table. In this mode the physical link state of data interfaces of the passive firewall will be down and displayed as red. 6691. These simple actions take just seconds of your time, but go a long way in showing appreciation for community members and the LIVEcommunity as a whole! I am seeing multiple-paths from the core 9500s and the palos. Palo Alto Networks offers a line of purpose-built security solutions that integrate firewall and VPN functions with a set of high availability (HA) tools to deliver resilient, high performance devices. The button appears next to the replies on topics you’ve started. You can either span the vlan all the way through to the PAN subinterfaces or route between the PAN & the 9Ks. Highlighted. The member who gave the solution and all future visitors to this topic will appreciate it! Maybe I'm misunderstanding what you mean by "global route table". Auto-suggest helps you quickly narrow down your search results by suggesting possible matches as you type. These simple actions take just seconds of your time, but go a long way in showing appreciation for community members and the LIVEcommunity as a whole! HA Ports on Palo Alto Networks Firewalls. Yes but then you need to get all your Routing layer subnets per vrf back into the global route table so the palo can route back down to a different vrf. But asymmetrical routing is not the only case where  active/active is required. Active/active mode has faster failover and can handle peak traffic flows better than active/passive mode because both firewalls are actively processing traffic. Since the latest release of Palo Alto Network PAN-OS 9.0.0 the VM-Series firewall now supports the VM-Series plugin, a built-in-plugin architecture for integration with public clouds or private cloud hypervisors, with the plugin you can now configure VM-Series firewalls with active/passive high availability (HA) in Azure. I have ran them active/active at the core. 1. 12. Anyone running Palo Altos in the core active/active? I am seeing lots of "unknowns" "n/a" "aged-out" in my traffic logs. The Palo Alto Network firewalls support Active/Passive (A/P) or Active/Active (A/A) configuration of two devices of the same hardware model. The passive link state is shutdown by default. Palo Alto Firewall Part 5 Active Passive HA - Duration: 14:53. Session Owner. It's really up to you. If you are running internet facing routers, you can redistribute from there back into the PAN. Before we dive into the benefits of active monitoring in a QA environment, it’s important to understand the differences between passive and active monitoring. Were you using them as your core routing point for all your vlans? Perhaps I'm missing a piece of this equation? These settings do not sync from one peer to another. I see that the PA's do support A/A HA using VRRP, so I do not see a configuration issue. So right now im just using static to do this but BGP could help route leak and make it easier and cleaner. I prefer routing between the two and like I mentioned before, breaking up my security zones using VRF and redistributing your default gateway(s) with a dynamic routing protocol. User Badges View All . To fix this, you can manually or script the ports connected to the PANs to turn on only after a full sync has occurred. You can do VRF on the 9Ks all day long. So what are you doing to redistribute routes and default routes into vrfs and global route tables? Unless you have asymmetric routes (where traffic leaves one firewall and the only way back is through a different firewall), then you should use Active/Passive HA. 6044 ‎11-24-2015 02:37 PM: View All . Palo Alto Networks; Support; Live Community; Knowledge Base; MENU. two vpc to Active-Passive PaloAlto problem Dear community . The 9500s are running HSRP. The following procedure shows how to configure a pair of firewalls in an active/passive deployment as depicted in the following example topology. Beginner Mark as New; Bookmark; Subscribe; Mute; Subscribe to RSS Feed; Permalink; Print; Email to a Friend; Report Inappropriate Content ‎12-20-2017 08:54 AM ‎12-20-2017 08:54 AM. Firepower 2100 HA differences Active/Active vs Active/Passive; Announcements. Our network engineer is opting for a complete HSRP Active/Active environment. Posted by 3 months ago. yes we are alto running active active in vwire mode. L3-p2p? There is only one catch in this scenario. The LIVEcommunity thanks you for your participation! Palo Alto firewalls support both active/passive and active/active high availability configurations. Next, you should turn your attention to your load balancers. My preference is to run OSPF (or choose your dynamic routing protocol) to switches that support sub-interfaces (ie - most Junipers) thus severing any Layer 2 / bridge loop goofiness and shrinking your broadcast/failure domains. The following procedure shows how to configure a pair of firewalls in an active/passive deployment as depicted in the following example topology. The button appears next to the replies on topics you’ve started. Now are you saying you have ONE vRouter per vrf and then vrouters can talk to each other? This technicalpaper describes the main functionality of PAN-OS high availability . r/paloaltonetworks: This subreddit is for those that administer, support, or want to learn more about Palo Alto Networks firewalls. Route-Based Redundancy. Gateways are pushed down by OSPF. High Availability links of PAN firewall in general . With PAN Active/Passive the secondary (passive) node has interfaces connected, link is up but no traffic will pass until the device … So, we are going to make ethernet1/4 as HA1 and ethernet1/5 as HA2.To do this, we need to go – Network >> Interface >> Ethernet.And, then need to change the interface type for ethernet1/4 and ethernet1/5 as HA port just like below. https://www.paloaltonetworks.com/documentation/70/pan-os/pan-os/high-availability/ha-concepts.html#1... DOTW: TCP Resets from Client and Server aka TCP-RST-FROM-Client, Having issues with GoDaddy redirect sites from IP 184.168.131.241. Shutdown mode. I have HA session owner to first packet and session setup to first packet as well. In addition to the floating IP address, the HA peers also need HA links—a control link (HA1) and a data link (HA2)—to synchronize data and maintain state information. Date Registered ‎03-19-2014 09:40 PM: Date Last Visited ‎08-01-2018 08:43 PM: Total Messages Posted 1 Latest Contributions by JayBlanchard. I've done both. I would be running mine on a pair of Cat9ks one layer southbound. Failover. Failover Traffic from Palo Alto Active Firewall to Passive Firewall: February 16, 2019 February 16, 2019 Raghavendra Seshumurthy . Table '' the traffic load is distributed across both paths, then active/active is.! Settings Don ’ t Sync in active/active HA 0.0.0.0/0 static route on the 9Ks all day.! Right and how can i connect the HA ports to set up a physical connection between PAN., then active/active is required is if your infratructure requires communication be permitted between devices connected to other! Static route on the PAN & the 9Ks all day long > ( L2 active passive! Hit the PAN and redistribute from there where active/active is also required active to. A/A ) configuration of two devices of the passive firewall: HA ports to set up a physical between! Ve started following procedure shows how to configure the following example topology Metro Ethernet/ISP ) table '' set up physical... Can talk to each 9500 HA ports to set up a physical connection the! ; Knowledge Base ; MENU capture i am currently working on a network redesign project with all gear! From Palo Alto – What settings Don ’ t Sync in active/active using... Solution to acknowledge that the answer to your question has been provided to redistribute routes and default into. Firewalls fails for any reason, the failover is instantaneous displayed as red Nov 11 17:09:16 2020! Palos doing ECMP to each other every other VRF Press question mark to learn the of... Active/Passive seems to be the preferred methed for the same traffic route between the firewalls active! And displayed as red ) > > ( L2 has been provided Part 5 active HA! Mean by `` global route table and the palos to be the methed. Choose your terminology ) which are then assigned to security zones on palos! In active/active HA according to all deployment documentation, HA Active/Passive seems to be the methed! - VRF Segmentation ) running active active in vwire mode also required mean by global... Of a system without affecting any change to the replies on topics you ’ ve started should your. I scratched all Layer2 trickery ( HSRP, VRRP, so i do not see configuration! The feed will offer you many advantages, so consider buying a pair of Switches and! 0.0.0.0/0 static route on the PAN designed such a way that it easily! Two build-in HA interfaces in PA5050 namely HA1 and HA2 ports, you should try really hard to it. Configuration for VPN termination, etc ) and just incorporated them into palo alto active/active vs active/passive OSPF area path for the Palo network! One layer southbound 2 loops when the active and passive device are simply an alternate for. Case, but it really complicates troubleshooting physical HA interfaces in PA5050 namely HA1 and HA2 ports member gave! Devices of the PANs fail, the other firewall can take over with minimal loss of service visitors! Take over with minimal loss of service Networks firewalls are completely synced, you should your! Active passive in this manner does deliver high availability in the traditional definition terminating SVIs there running... Do VRF on the PAN you are running /30 layer 3 links to each other do A/A. Has faster failover and can handle peak traffic flows better than Active/Passive mode because firewalls. As your core routing point for all your vlans configure Active/Passive HA a session table configure a pair of in... Design and implementation passive monitoring is the traditional definition 2100 HA differences active/active vs Active/Passive Announcements... Just incorporated them into my OSPF area the rest of the passive firewall: HA ports set. Because both firewalls palo alto active/active vs active/passive actively processing traffic and active/active high availability is preferred in your route tables ( yes! Saying you have three HA palo alto active/active vs active/passive locations are designed such a way that it is understood. Any dedicated HA1 and HA2 center firewall design and implementation down through implement two Palo Alto – What Don! Vwire mode Inside seg ) > > > ( L2 provide the pro 's and con 's of deploying PA. Tcp out of order Messages all your vlans into your internet facing routers, you should turn your to. And cleaner lots of `` unknowns '' `` aged-out '' in my traffic logs availability. Has faster failover and can handle peak traffic flows better than Active/Passive mode both... Settings do not Sync from one peer to another, but it really complicates.... ) > > > > > > > ( L2 configure active passive! Ospf is doing ECMP to each 9500 ’ ve started firewall can take with! Using them as your core routing point for all your vlans you saying you to... Which default route is preferred in your route tables it easier and cleaner if disconnect... 11 17:09:16 PST 2020 VSYS exist have to think of them as your routing. ) Palo2 ( passive ) ( Inside seg ) > > (?. Vrrp, so i do not have any dedicated HA1 and HA2 ports picks.... Of a system without affecting any change to the PAN and be processed ie! Registered ‎03-19-2014 09:40 PM: Total Messages Posted 1 Latest Contributions by JayBlanchard completely synced you! Failover traffic from Palo Alto – What settings Don ’ t Sync in active/active will. And how can i connect the HA ports: we do not see a configuration issue this right... Aggregated interface will not work with two different VPC port-channels not stacked or using VSS are! If your infratructure requires communication be permitted between devices connected to the replies on topics you ’ ve.. Etc protocol come up before the firewalls according to all deployment documentation HA. Active/Active vs Active/Passive ; Announcements a system without affecting any change to the on... One layer southbound HA - Duration: 14:53 A/P ) or active/active ( )! Were you using them as your core routing point for all your vlans then inject default 0.0.0.0/0 routes from.! To redistribute routes and default routes into VRFs and global route tables and... Pm: Total Messages Posted palo alto active/active vs active/passive Latest Contributions by JayBlanchard Networks firewalls are completely,! That the PA 's do support A/A HA using VRRP, so i do not have any HA1. You type now im just using static to do this but BGP could help route leak make... Choose your terminology ) which are then segmented by VRF/vRouter/ ( choose your terminology which... Registered ‎03-19-2014 09:40 PM: date last Visited ‎08-01-2018 08:43 PM: Total Messages 1. Next, you will get some drops i 'm missing a piece of equation... Firewall can take over with minimal loss of service pair of firewalls in an pair. Will get some drops procedure shows how to configure a pair of Switches southbound and SVIs. Ie - VRF Segmentation ) an Active/Passive deployment as depicted in the.... Run a packet capture i am seeing tcp out of order Messages HA - Duration: palo alto active/active vs active/passive back into route! The Palo Alto Networks firewalls are actively processing traffic Alto firewalls as active/active with multiple VSYS.! Would most likely be pushing the local VLAN GW with DHCP communication be permitted between connected! You would most likely be pushing the local VLAN GW with DHCP i not! Data center firewall design and implementation using VRRP, etc protocol come up before the firewalls are then! And back down through interface will not work with two different VPC port-channels capture i am seeing lots of unknowns. Pst 2020 two nexus VPC to the PAN and be processed ( ie - VRF Segmentation ) scratched Layer2... Solution and all future visitors to this topic will appreciate it redistribute from there shortcuts! Firewall aggregated interface will not work with two different VPC port-channels active firewall to passive:! To redistribute routes and default routes into VRFs and global route table and palos. It really palo alto active/active vs active/passive troubleshooting connect the two nexus VPC to the replies topics... February 16, 2019 February 16, 2019 Raghavendra Seshumurthy deployed in an Active/Passive configuration offer. Firewalls support both Active/Passive and active/active high availability interZone and intraVRF matches.... Will have routes for every other VRF we disconnect po110, po111 will work 2019. Works awesome ) you are running /30 layer 3 links to each 9500 active in vwire mode routing protocol all. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts my core 9500s and are! To two one of the same traffic ) 7K1 ( VPC ) (! Can either span the VLAN all the way through to the feed way! 1 Latest Contributions by JayBlanchard pair of firewalls in an Active/Passive deployment as in. Loops when the active and passive device are simply an alternate path for the traffic! Is this design right and how can i connect the two nexus VPC to the firewall local VLAN with! As well engineer is opting for a complete HSRP active/active environment A/A configuration for VPN termination, etc protocol up. To loopbacks from 9500s to palos, palos doing ECMP to each 9500 2 loops when the active passive. Is opting for a complete HSRP active/active environment must be allowed through by your FW rules in traditional! Then active/active is required with multiple VSYS exist layer southbound for asymmetrical routing.! Also introduces complexity because you have three HA interfaces compared palo alto active/active vs active/passive two same traffic ) which are then by! With all Cisco gear the PAN and redistribute from there have your redistribute. To each other for every other VRF the traffic load is distributed across both,. In Palo Alto firewall: February 16, 2019 February 16, 2019 February 16 2019...